Philippians 3:4b-14
“Break the Cycle”
Preached Sunday, October 4, 2026
Let’s jump right into it - this is one of those passages of Scripture that it feels unsettling to say “The Word of God for the people of God - Thanks be to God” after it. Thanks be to God for…that? For a disturbing passage that depicts violence that has been used to condone violence?
Because let’s get that right out of the way - this passage has been used - historically and even today - to promote a supersessionist theology that Christianity has replaced Judaism and that hate and violence against the Jewish people, as the rejectors of Christ (which is not entirely true) is justified.
Violence is never justified and especially not by Scripture, however it may be misused and abused to do so.
So let’s look at this passage and see what God has to say to us today about the cycles of violence that exist in our world.
The start of this chapter in Matthew involves Jesus flipping over the tables in the temple - angry that those there were taking advantage of the poor by overcharging for the needed sacrifices. This puts Jesus head to head with the religious leaders - they come to him and ask “By whose authority do you say and do these things?” And thus Jesus enters into some verbal sparring over John the Baptist and he tells them two parables. The second of which is this one that we call The Parable of the Wicked Tenants.
There was a landowner who had a vineyard - and he leased it to tenants. When it was time for the harvest, he sent three servants to collect the harvest - but the tenants beat one, stoned one, and killed one. The landowner decided to try again - he sent three servants to collect the harvest. But again, the tenants beat one, stoned one, and killed one. And so, at this point, the landowner decides to send his son - surely they will respect him!, he thinks - but the tenants see a chance to gain the son’s inheritance and kill the son as well.
Let’s talk about the traditional interpretation of this parable for a moment. The landowner is God. The vineyard, the Kingdom of God or the people of Israel. The tenants are the leaders of the Jewish people. The servants who are beaten, stoned, and killed are the prophets. The son that is killed - Jesus.
Jesus ends here in the telling of this parable and he turns to the religious leaders to whom he is telling this story too and he asks them to write the ending. He says, “When the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those tenants?” It is the religious leaders who say, “He will put the wretches to a miserable death” and give the land to other tenants who will give the landowner the harvest.
Now, Jesus continues here talking about the cornerstone that has been rejected but I want to keep our focus on the parable and the ending of the parable. The ending we are given - that the current tenants are killed and replaced - was never said by Jesus. Because that is not how God ends this story.
Given the traditional interpretation of the servants being the prophets and the son being Jesus - when Jesus is rejected and killed - how does God respond?
The end to this story where the wicked tenants are killed and replaced is NOT the ending God in Jesus gives this story - it is the ending the religious leaders who have little imagination give to the ending. In fact, not just religious leaders, but as humans - this is the ending so many of us would give because it is near impossible for us to see beyond the cycles of violence that we are trapped in. We live in an eye for an eye world. Tit for tat. They hit us so we hit back harder. The human imagination struggles to imagine a world that does not continue the perpetuation of violence. We lament, it’s just the way of this world! We continue to bomb each other, go to war, carry out the death penalty, and are a people who wield death.
I think we’re trapped in these cycles of violence for a lot of reasons…one of those reasons is we are obsessed with protecting what is “ours” and with winning. That’s one of the things that is worth pointing out in this parable - the tenants are literally killing people over something that isn’t even theirs. And they kill the son thinking they will steal his inheritance…and that makes no sense, that’s not how inheritance works! But they viewed the land they lived on as theirs…and thus would “protect” it at all costs. And I am going to say something that sounds very much like a preacher today, and I know that, but hear me out:
Nothing is ours. Everything is God’s.
I know, I know. I know how that sounds. Like a preacher’s platitude. It’s so anticultural for us too. Capitalism tells us that what’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours and don’t you dare touch what is mine. But Scripture tells us that the Earth and everything in it is the Lord’s. The whole world is the vineyard and we are just its tenants who are called to give everything to the landlord of the vineyard, everything to God.
So let’s look at this passage and see what God has to say to us today about the cycles of violence that exist in our world.
The start of this chapter in Matthew involves Jesus flipping over the tables in the temple - angry that those there were taking advantage of the poor by overcharging for the needed sacrifices. This puts Jesus head to head with the religious leaders - they come to him and ask “By whose authority do you say and do these things?” And thus Jesus enters into some verbal sparring over John the Baptist and he tells them two parables. The second of which is this one that we call The Parable of the Wicked Tenants.
There was a landowner who had a vineyard - and he leased it to tenants. When it was time for the harvest, he sent three servants to collect the harvest - but the tenants beat one, stoned one, and killed one. The landowner decided to try again - he sent three servants to collect the harvest. But again, the tenants beat one, stoned one, and killed one. And so, at this point, the landowner decides to send his son - surely they will respect him!, he thinks - but the tenants see a chance to gain the son’s inheritance and kill the son as well.
Let’s talk about the traditional interpretation of this parable for a moment. The landowner is God. The vineyard, the Kingdom of God or the people of Israel. The tenants are the leaders of the Jewish people. The servants who are beaten, stoned, and killed are the prophets. The son that is killed - Jesus.
Jesus ends here in the telling of this parable and he turns to the religious leaders to whom he is telling this story too and he asks them to write the ending. He says, “When the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those tenants?” It is the religious leaders who say, “He will put the wretches to a miserable death” and give the land to other tenants who will give the landowner the harvest.
Now, Jesus continues here talking about the cornerstone that has been rejected but I want to keep our focus on the parable and the ending of the parable. The ending we are given - that the current tenants are killed and replaced - was never said by Jesus. Because that is not how God ends this story.
Given the traditional interpretation of the servants being the prophets and the son being Jesus - when Jesus is rejected and killed - how does God respond?
The end to this story where the wicked tenants are killed and replaced is NOT the ending God in Jesus gives this story - it is the ending the religious leaders who have little imagination give to the ending. In fact, not just religious leaders, but as humans - this is the ending so many of us would give because it is near impossible for us to see beyond the cycles of violence that we are trapped in. We live in an eye for an eye world. Tit for tat. They hit us so we hit back harder. The human imagination struggles to imagine a world that does not continue the perpetuation of violence. We lament, it’s just the way of this world! We continue to bomb each other, go to war, carry out the death penalty, and are a people who wield death.
I think we’re trapped in these cycles of violence for a lot of reasons…one of those reasons is we are obsessed with protecting what is “ours” and with winning. That’s one of the things that is worth pointing out in this parable - the tenants are literally killing people over something that isn’t even theirs. And they kill the son thinking they will steal his inheritance…and that makes no sense, that’s not how inheritance works! But they viewed the land they lived on as theirs…and thus would “protect” it at all costs. And I am going to say something that sounds very much like a preacher today, and I know that, but hear me out:
Nothing is ours. Everything is God’s.
I know, I know. I know how that sounds. Like a preacher’s platitude. It’s so anticultural for us too. Capitalism tells us that what’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours and don’t you dare touch what is mine. But Scripture tells us that the Earth and everything in it is the Lord’s. The whole world is the vineyard and we are just its tenants who are called to give everything to the landlord of the vineyard, everything to God.
I’m not saying we should sell all our possessions, give the money to the poor, and follow Jesus - although Jesus himself said as such to at least one person. What I am saying is we need to hold all that we think is “ours” more loosely. How many wars have been started over borders? How many wars have been started over the fight over natural resources? How many wars continue over generations of fighting over land? Gaza is a prime example of this. Generations and endless cycles of violence and so, so many children killed (In June the UN reported 22,000 Palestinian children killed and 44,000 injured in Gaza since October 2023) …at what point do we as humans break the endless cycle of violence? How long, O Lord, how long?
Many native people, including the Indigenous people in the US, had no concept of ownership of the land. We could not own the land - the land belonged to itself. The land and its resources belong to God. They are not ours to exploit, to use up, to fight over - they are ours to steward, to take care of, to share.
Our obsession with what is “ours” also takes place on smaller scales than international wars. How many neighbors have you heard who feud with each other over their property lines? How many stories have you heard from churches of different ministries or groups infighting with each other when they should be sharing a mutual mission?
In his book, “Not In It To Win It” by Pastor Andy Stanley, he says that American culture values winning above all else. Now, disclaimer, I haven’t read this book but my mother has multiple times and keeps on begging me to read it - I know you’re listening to my sermon online, Mom. He says this in particular comes out in our political system and it affects every area of our lives, including the Church and how we live as Christians. But Jesus shows us another way. Stanley says, “in an ancient culture that worships winning, the message of Jesus was considered weak. Offensive. Appalling. Something to be canceled. Violently if need be… But Jesus’s others-first value system appealed to many. Christians refused to abandon the sick. The adopted abandoned children. They extended compassion and generosity to people and groups who couldn’t or would not return the favor. They deemed women equal to men. Slaves were to be treated as brothers…” But first, we need to give up our endless desire to be right, to win, to own and protect what is “ours” - for nothing is ours - everything is God’s.
Paul says as much in our reading from Philippians today: “Yet whatever gains I had, these I have come to regard as loss because of Christ. More than that, I regard everything as loss because of the surpassing value of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For his sake I have suffered the loss of all things, and I regard them as rubbish, in order that I may gain Christ and be found in him.”
In order to gain Christ - we have to stop trying to win. Win the games of this world. Win the battles, win the war, protect what is ours - ideological or literal. In order to break the cycles of violence that have trapped us - we need to be able to let go of all that we hold on to too tightly and imagine another way, another outcome. We need God-sized imaginations.
Every week in the pastoral prayer I pray, “may minds turn from war to peace and may weapons be beaten into plowshares.” This is a direct reference to Isaiah - the day of the Lord when it is on earth as it is in heaven. Weapons, which are death wielding, are transformed into plowshares - farm equipment, something that literally creates food, that is life-giving. But to go from death-wielding to life-giving, especially in our world where we are trapped in the cycles of retribution, of war, of endless violence - it requires a holy imagination. An imagination that the religious leaders did not have that day when they said the wicked tenants would be killed and replaced. This is such a human answer - and probably a similar one to how most people in our world would answer today.
Thank God that the death of the tenants is not the ending God would write for this story. God’s imagination was and is bigger than that, bigger than our cycles violence. Because God did send prophets who were rejected, beaten, stoned, and killed. And then God sent God’s son, God’s self in Jesus, who was caught up in the cycles of violence in this world, rejected by those who he came to save, and on whom the state carried out the death penalty. If God was telling this story to us today - and we didn’t know the ending yet - and we were asked - what should God do? Our answer would look a lot like the religious leaders’ of Jesus’s day - get even, retaliate. Make them pay.
But that is not the ending God in Jesus chooses. When Jesus is rejected, tortured, and killed…God does not allow Death and Violence to have the final say.
Our God who in Ezekiel said, “Say to them: As I live, says the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked but that the wicked turn from their ways and live;” and in Isaiah said:
“He shall judge between the nations
and shall arbitrate for many peoples;
they shall beat their swords into plowshares
and their spears into pruning hooks;
nation shall not lift up sword against nation;
neither shall they learn war any more”;
And in Jesus said, “You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye, and tooth for tooth.’ But I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other cheek also.”
This God wrote a different ending than the one the religious leaders would have written, that humanity would have written - because our God has a holy and God sized imagination for a world that could be - and one day will be.
God’s ending was that when Jesus died on the cross, when Jesus went into the tomb, God broke the cycle of violence, God broke the cycle of Death - and Jesus rose from the dead. Violence did not have the final say. Death did not have the final say. Retribution did not have the final say - because instead of condemning those who killed Jesus - and instead of condemning us for our endless cycles of violence and our obsessions with winning and what’s “ours” - in the resurrection of Jesus, we are offered reconciliation over retribution. We are offered repentance over condemnation. We are offered peace over strife. We are offered life over death! We are offered another ending that we could not write for ourselves! We are offered a place in the Kingdom of God - a Kingdom of Peace that one day, thanks to God’s God sized imagination - we will have a place and a part in!
Before I end my sermon today - I want to give us some hope. Because we know the ending that God wrote, because God chose life over death, and because God has told us the ultimate ending - that one day Death will hold no sway over any of us, and all the earth, all creation will be redeemed and all people will live in peace with God and one another - because God showed us a new way, a different way, a way of peace in Jesus - we too can break the cycles of violence in our world today and chose a different way, a way of life, we too can write endings of peace.
This week is Nonviolence Week in the state of Ohio and the city of Youngstown. One of the goals of this week is to share the six principles of nonviolence and help people live into them. Martin Luther King’s 6 Principles of Nonviolence are as follows:
“1. Nonviolence is a way of life for courageous people.
2. Nonviolence seeks to win friendship and understanding.
3. Nonviolence seeks to defeat injustice, not people.
4. Nonviolence holds that voluntary suffering can educate and transform.
5. Nonviolence chooses love instead of hate.
6. Nonviolence believes that the universe is on the side of justice.”
I want to share with you a story of nonviolence that is not new but is new to me. During the Liberian Civil War, while men were the primary people who carried out acts of violence and war, women (and children) were the ones who carried much of the impact of the violence of the war - as it so often happens. Many of these women had their children kidnapped - their sons drugged and forced to fight, to even kill their own families. Their daughters raped and trafficked to soldiers. Their husbands and fathers - brutally murdered in front of them. Many of these women decided they could no longer endure the violence and burden of war - they had to act without continuing the cycles of violence. They banded together and formed a coalition of mothers and women who used nonviolent tactics to bring about peace and end the war.
“In 2003, during the Second Liberian Civil War, Women of Liberia Mass Action for Peace forced a meeting with President Charles Taylor and extracted a promise from him to attend peace talks in Ghana to negotiate with the rebels from Liberians United for Reconciliation and Democracy and Movement for Democracy in Liberia. A delegation of Liberian women went to Ghana to continue to apply pressure on the warring factions during the peace process.
Two hundred women surrounded the room, dressed in white, dominating the conversation. Any time the negotiators tried to leave, the women threatened to take off all of their clothes. Enclosed in the room with the women, the men would try to jump out of the windows to escape their talk. But the women persisted, staging a sit-in outside of the Presidential Palace. They blocked all the doors and windows and prevented anyone from leaving the peace talks without a resolution.” (Wikipedia)
Due to their nonviolent actions, a peace agreement was reached, ending a 14 year civil war.
Their story gives me goosebumps - and it gives me hope.
Lastly, today is World Communion Sunday. Today we recognize that this table we come to, this holy meal, this sacrament we share - is not ours. It is not Boardman UMC’s. It is not the United Methodist Church’s. It doesn’t belong to Christians in our country alone. This is a worldwide table that unites people of many identities, many nationalities, many ethnicities - and in this table, we can celebrate what makes each of us unique - but there is no “mine” and “yours” - there is no “winning” or “losing” - there is just shared identity as children of God. And Children of God are called to love one another. Children of God cannot come to this table and continue the cycles of violence against other children of God. And so the very act of coming to this table, when we take it seriously, is an act of breaking cycles of violence.
And so my prayer for us today and every day is that weapons would be beaten into plowshares, that we would count all as loss in Christ Jesus, that we could have holy and God sized imaginations, and write a different ending than the endings our world would write - may we break the cycles of violence and be a people of peace.
May it be so. Amen.
Many native people, including the Indigenous people in the US, had no concept of ownership of the land. We could not own the land - the land belonged to itself. The land and its resources belong to God. They are not ours to exploit, to use up, to fight over - they are ours to steward, to take care of, to share.
Our obsession with what is “ours” also takes place on smaller scales than international wars. How many neighbors have you heard who feud with each other over their property lines? How many stories have you heard from churches of different ministries or groups infighting with each other when they should be sharing a mutual mission?
In his book, “Not In It To Win It” by Pastor Andy Stanley, he says that American culture values winning above all else. Now, disclaimer, I haven’t read this book but my mother has multiple times and keeps on begging me to read it - I know you’re listening to my sermon online, Mom. He says this in particular comes out in our political system and it affects every area of our lives, including the Church and how we live as Christians. But Jesus shows us another way. Stanley says, “in an ancient culture that worships winning, the message of Jesus was considered weak. Offensive. Appalling. Something to be canceled. Violently if need be… But Jesus’s others-first value system appealed to many. Christians refused to abandon the sick. The adopted abandoned children. They extended compassion and generosity to people and groups who couldn’t or would not return the favor. They deemed women equal to men. Slaves were to be treated as brothers…” But first, we need to give up our endless desire to be right, to win, to own and protect what is “ours” - for nothing is ours - everything is God’s.
Paul says as much in our reading from Philippians today: “Yet whatever gains I had, these I have come to regard as loss because of Christ. More than that, I regard everything as loss because of the surpassing value of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For his sake I have suffered the loss of all things, and I regard them as rubbish, in order that I may gain Christ and be found in him.”
In order to gain Christ - we have to stop trying to win. Win the games of this world. Win the battles, win the war, protect what is ours - ideological or literal. In order to break the cycles of violence that have trapped us - we need to be able to let go of all that we hold on to too tightly and imagine another way, another outcome. We need God-sized imaginations.
Every week in the pastoral prayer I pray, “may minds turn from war to peace and may weapons be beaten into plowshares.” This is a direct reference to Isaiah - the day of the Lord when it is on earth as it is in heaven. Weapons, which are death wielding, are transformed into plowshares - farm equipment, something that literally creates food, that is life-giving. But to go from death-wielding to life-giving, especially in our world where we are trapped in the cycles of retribution, of war, of endless violence - it requires a holy imagination. An imagination that the religious leaders did not have that day when they said the wicked tenants would be killed and replaced. This is such a human answer - and probably a similar one to how most people in our world would answer today.
Thank God that the death of the tenants is not the ending God would write for this story. God’s imagination was and is bigger than that, bigger than our cycles violence. Because God did send prophets who were rejected, beaten, stoned, and killed. And then God sent God’s son, God’s self in Jesus, who was caught up in the cycles of violence in this world, rejected by those who he came to save, and on whom the state carried out the death penalty. If God was telling this story to us today - and we didn’t know the ending yet - and we were asked - what should God do? Our answer would look a lot like the religious leaders’ of Jesus’s day - get even, retaliate. Make them pay.
But that is not the ending God in Jesus chooses. When Jesus is rejected, tortured, and killed…God does not allow Death and Violence to have the final say.
Our God who in Ezekiel said, “Say to them: As I live, says the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked but that the wicked turn from their ways and live;” and in Isaiah said:
“He shall judge between the nations
and shall arbitrate for many peoples;
they shall beat their swords into plowshares
and their spears into pruning hooks;
nation shall not lift up sword against nation;
neither shall they learn war any more”;
And in Jesus said, “You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye, and tooth for tooth.’ But I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other cheek also.”
This God wrote a different ending than the one the religious leaders would have written, that humanity would have written - because our God has a holy and God sized imagination for a world that could be - and one day will be.
God’s ending was that when Jesus died on the cross, when Jesus went into the tomb, God broke the cycle of violence, God broke the cycle of Death - and Jesus rose from the dead. Violence did not have the final say. Death did not have the final say. Retribution did not have the final say - because instead of condemning those who killed Jesus - and instead of condemning us for our endless cycles of violence and our obsessions with winning and what’s “ours” - in the resurrection of Jesus, we are offered reconciliation over retribution. We are offered repentance over condemnation. We are offered peace over strife. We are offered life over death! We are offered another ending that we could not write for ourselves! We are offered a place in the Kingdom of God - a Kingdom of Peace that one day, thanks to God’s God sized imagination - we will have a place and a part in!
Before I end my sermon today - I want to give us some hope. Because we know the ending that God wrote, because God chose life over death, and because God has told us the ultimate ending - that one day Death will hold no sway over any of us, and all the earth, all creation will be redeemed and all people will live in peace with God and one another - because God showed us a new way, a different way, a way of peace in Jesus - we too can break the cycles of violence in our world today and chose a different way, a way of life, we too can write endings of peace.
This week is Nonviolence Week in the state of Ohio and the city of Youngstown. One of the goals of this week is to share the six principles of nonviolence and help people live into them. Martin Luther King’s 6 Principles of Nonviolence are as follows:
“1. Nonviolence is a way of life for courageous people.
2. Nonviolence seeks to win friendship and understanding.
3. Nonviolence seeks to defeat injustice, not people.
4. Nonviolence holds that voluntary suffering can educate and transform.
5. Nonviolence chooses love instead of hate.
6. Nonviolence believes that the universe is on the side of justice.”
I want to share with you a story of nonviolence that is not new but is new to me. During the Liberian Civil War, while men were the primary people who carried out acts of violence and war, women (and children) were the ones who carried much of the impact of the violence of the war - as it so often happens. Many of these women had their children kidnapped - their sons drugged and forced to fight, to even kill their own families. Their daughters raped and trafficked to soldiers. Their husbands and fathers - brutally murdered in front of them. Many of these women decided they could no longer endure the violence and burden of war - they had to act without continuing the cycles of violence. They banded together and formed a coalition of mothers and women who used nonviolent tactics to bring about peace and end the war.
“In 2003, during the Second Liberian Civil War, Women of Liberia Mass Action for Peace forced a meeting with President Charles Taylor and extracted a promise from him to attend peace talks in Ghana to negotiate with the rebels from Liberians United for Reconciliation and Democracy and Movement for Democracy in Liberia. A delegation of Liberian women went to Ghana to continue to apply pressure on the warring factions during the peace process.
Two hundred women surrounded the room, dressed in white, dominating the conversation. Any time the negotiators tried to leave, the women threatened to take off all of their clothes. Enclosed in the room with the women, the men would try to jump out of the windows to escape their talk. But the women persisted, staging a sit-in outside of the Presidential Palace. They blocked all the doors and windows and prevented anyone from leaving the peace talks without a resolution.” (Wikipedia)
Due to their nonviolent actions, a peace agreement was reached, ending a 14 year civil war.
Their story gives me goosebumps - and it gives me hope.
Lastly, today is World Communion Sunday. Today we recognize that this table we come to, this holy meal, this sacrament we share - is not ours. It is not Boardman UMC’s. It is not the United Methodist Church’s. It doesn’t belong to Christians in our country alone. This is a worldwide table that unites people of many identities, many nationalities, many ethnicities - and in this table, we can celebrate what makes each of us unique - but there is no “mine” and “yours” - there is no “winning” or “losing” - there is just shared identity as children of God. And Children of God are called to love one another. Children of God cannot come to this table and continue the cycles of violence against other children of God. And so the very act of coming to this table, when we take it seriously, is an act of breaking cycles of violence.
And so my prayer for us today and every day is that weapons would be beaten into plowshares, that we would count all as loss in Christ Jesus, that we could have holy and God sized imaginations, and write a different ending than the endings our world would write - may we break the cycles of violence and be a people of peace.
May it be so. Amen.